Create Account
Manage my channels
Watch later and create collections
Manage your email subscriptions
Exclusive offers and opportunities
00:00:00 - Introduction
00:01:22 - Ortlund's Logical Argument
00:03:50 - Suan's Basic Point
00:16:05 - Suan's Pragmatic Argument
00:17:31 - Responding to Ortlund
00:22:07 - Fallible List = Disaster
00:23:36 - 1. Burden Problem
00:24:17 - 2. Impartiality Problem
00:31:00 - 3. Disclosure Problem
00:33:29 - 4. Legitimacy Problem
00:37:55 - Removing Books
00:39:59 - Summary
00:41:13 - Gavin's Historical Argument
00:43:36 - New Testament Canon
00:44:37 - 1. Nicaea
00:47:13 - 2. Josephus
01:05:06 - 3. Luke 24.44
01:08:41 - 3.1. Gavin's comment
01:11:15 - 3.2. Contradiction and Misrepresentation
01:12:58 - 3.3. Uncharitable and Precision
01:14:40 - Lee Martin McDonald
01:17:17 - First-Century Judaism
01:20:14 - Catholic Model of Canonization
01:26:34 - Jerome vs. Augustine (Consensus)
01:29:34 - Why was the canon settled later?
01:31:39 - Summary
01:33:18 - 3 Protestant Objections
01:33:26 - OBJ1: Tu Quoque!
01:42:36 - OBJ2: Consensus
01:51:53 - 3 Protestant Inconsistencies
01:54:57 - OBJ3: Inerrant Canon
01:58:11 - Conclusion
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/intellectualcatholicism
Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/intellectual-catholicism/id1550879909
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/intellectualcatholicism
Suan Sonna is a Baptist convert to Catholicism who is dedicated to curating the best Catholic intellectual content on philosophy, politics, and theology. He is also passionate about engaging people outside of the Catholic tradition on issues relevant to the Church.